Information Warfare
When Your Government Is the Propagandist
The Pentagon spends $4.7 billion per year on public relations — more than the combined budgets of NPR, PBS, the National Endowment for the Arts, and the National Endowment for the Humanities. Russia's Internet Research Agency spent just $1.25 million per month and reached 126 million Americans. In 2012, Congress quietly repealed the law banning the US government from directing propaganda at its own citizens. The battlefield is your mind, and you don't even know you're under fire.
$4.7B
Pentagon PR Budget
Annual — more than most news orgs combined
126M
Americans Reached
By Russian IRA on Facebook alone
27,000+
Military PR Personnel
More than all US journalists covering the Pentagon
2012
Domestic Propaganda Legalized
Smith-Mundt Act repealed
A Century of Government Propaganda
Government propaganda isn't new. What's new is the scale, the technology, and the fact that the legal barriers have been removed. Here's how we got here.
Committee on Public Information (CPI)
Woodrow Wilson created the CPI under George Creel to sell WWI to a skeptical American public. 75,000 "Four Minute Men" gave pro-war speeches in movie theaters. Created iconic "Uncle Sam Wants You" posters. Pioneered modern government propaganda — and it worked. Public opinion flipped from isolationist to interventionist in months.
Office of War Information (OWI)
FDR established OWI to coordinate wartime messaging. Controlled what journalists could report from the front. Hollywood became a propaganda arm — the Bureau of Motion Pictures reviewed scripts. Voice of America began broadcasting. Set the template for government-media cooperation that persists today.
Smith-Mundt Act
Congress recognized the danger of government propaganda aimed at its own citizens. The Smith-Mundt Act authorized the State Department to conduct public diplomacy abroad but explicitly BANNED domestic dissemination of those materials. For 64 years, this was the firewall between foreign propaganda and American citizens.
CIA Operation Mockingbird
The CIA recruited journalists at major outlets — Washington Post, Time, Newsweek, CBS — to plant stories favorable to US foreign policy. At its peak, the CIA had influence over 25+ newspapers and wire services. Journalist Carl Bernstein exposed the program in a 1977 Rolling Stone article: "The CIA and the Media."
Grenada Media Blackout
Reagan invaded Grenada and banned all journalists from the island for the first 2 days. The military controlled every image and narrative. No independent verification of government claims was possible. The template for "managed" war coverage was born.
Gulf War — The CNN War
Pentagon created the "pool system" — only approved journalists with military escorts could report. Smart bomb footage played on loop (only 7% of munitions were precision-guided, but 100% of footage showed them). Press conferences became the story. War became television entertainment.
Iraq War — Embedded Journalism
775 reporters were "embedded" with military units. Studies found embedded reporters produced coverage that was 90% positive toward the military. Independent journalists were sidelined or killed — Reuters cameraman Mazen Dana shot by US tank, Al Jazeera offices bombed. Jessica Lynch rescue was staged for cameras.
Smith-Mundt Modernization Act
Buried inside the 2013 NDAA, Congress quietly repealed the domestic propaganda ban. The US government could now legally direct propaganda at its own citizens. Representative Mac Thornberry called it a "modernization." Critics called it legalizing government lies to Americans.
Russian Internet Research Agency
A St. Petersburg troll farm with a $1.25 million/month budget ran a massive influence operation targeting the US election. Created fake American personas, organized real protests on both sides, and reached an estimated 126 million Americans through Facebook alone. 3,500+ Facebook ads. 10+ million tweets.
Cambridge Analytica Scandal
Harvested data from 87 million Facebook users without consent. Used psychographic profiling to micro-target political ads. Worked for the Trump campaign and the Brexit campaign. CEO Alexander Nix caught on hidden camera offering to use Ukrainian sex workers to entrap political opponents.
Deepfakes & AI Propaganda
AI-generated video can now put words in anyone's mouth. Pentagon awarded contracts for deepfake detection — and creation. In 2023, a deepfake image of a Pentagon explosion briefly caused the stock market to dip. The era of "seeing is believing" is over.
The Pentagon's $4.7 Billion PR Machine
The Department of Defense is the largest employer of public relations personnel in the world. A 2009 Associated Press investigation found the Pentagon employed 27,000 people for recruitment, advertising, and public relations — spending $4.7 billion per year. That's more than the GDP of some countries, all dedicated to shaping how Americans think about war.
| Category | Annual Spending | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Public Affairs Officers | $2.1B | 27,000+ personnel dedicated to managing the military's public image |
| Recruitment Advertising | $1.4B | Including $100M+ on esports, Twitch streams, and gaming sponsorships |
| Hollywood Liaison Office | Undisclosed | Script review and equipment access for favorable portrayals — Top Gun, Transformers, Marvel |
| Military Bands & Ceremonial | $437M | More than the entire budget of the National Endowment for the Arts ($167M) |
| Stars & Stripes Newspaper | $15.5M | Military-funded newspaper that Congress must repeatedly save from Pentagon defunding attempts |
| Sports Marketing | $53M | Paid patriotism — NFL flyovers, anthem ceremonies, and "hometown hero" segments |
| Social Media Operations | $250M+ | Managing official accounts, monitoring sentiment, and undisclosed influence operations |
Source: Associated Press investigation, 2009. Current spending likely higher but Pentagon resists disclosure.
The Death of Independent War Reporting
In Vietnam, journalists roamed freely. Their uncensored reporting — napalm girl, My Lai massacre, the Tet Offensive — turned public opinion against the war. The Pentagon learned a lesson from Vietnam, but it wasn't "don't commit atrocities." It was "don't let journalists see."
The Embedding System
In 2003, the Pentagon offered 775 reporter slots "embedded" with military units in Iraq. It seemed like unprecedented access. In reality, it was unprecedented control:
- ▸Stockholm syndrome by design: Reporters who ate, slept, and faced danger with troops developed loyalty to them. A Cardiff University study found embedded reporters were 90% positive in their coverage.
- ▸Narrowed perspective: Embedded reporters saw the war through a soda straw — their unit's experience. They couldn't see civilian casualties, strategic failures, or the big picture.
- ▸Non-embedded reporters targeted: Journalists operating independently in Iraq were killed at alarming rates. Reuters cameraman Mazen Dana was shot by a US tank. Al Jazeera offices were bombed in Kabul and Baghdad. The Palestine Hotel — known journalist base — was shelled by US forces, killing two cameramen.
- ▸Military approval required: Stories were reviewed before publication for "operational security." Reporters who filed unfavorable stories were dis-embedded — sent home.
"The embedding system is a brilliant, insidious corruption of the press. You cannot be objective about people who are saving your life."
— Chris Hedges, Pulitzer Prize-winning war correspondent
Social Media: The New Battlefield
The Internet Research Agency in St. Petersburg, Russia, operated with a monthly budget of just $1.25 million — less than the cost of a single Tomahawk cruise missile ($1.87M). Yet it arguably had more strategic impact than billions in conventional military spending. Every major power now runs information operations on social media.
Russian IRA (2016)
$1.25M/monthReach: 126M Americans on Facebook
Platforms: Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, YouTube, Reddit
Fake American personas, organized real-world protests on both sides, targeted African American voters with suppression messages, created 470 Facebook pages
Chinese 50 Cent Army
$0.08/post (estimated)Reach: 488M fabricated social media posts/year
Platforms: Weibo, WeChat, global platforms
Government employees post pro-CCP comments to "guide public opinion." Named for alleged payment of 50 cents (yuan) per post. Estimated 2 million+ participants.
Pentagon Info Ops
$4.7B total PR budgetReach: Unknown — classified
Platforms: Twitter, Facebook, Arabic-language platforms
In 2022, Meta and Twitter removed fake accounts linked to US military CENTCOM. Used fake personas to push pro-US narratives in Middle East and Central Asia.
Israeli Act.IL App
Government-fundedReach: 15,000+ volunteers
Platforms: Twitter, Facebook, TikTok
App sends "missions" to volunteers to like, share, or report specific content. Used to mass-report Palestinian accounts and boost pro-Israel content.
Saudi Arabia
$3.5B (estimated info ops)Reach: Thousands of accounts
Platforms: Twitter (heavy), YouTube
Army of Twitter bots pushing pro-MBS content. Recruited Twitter employee as spy. Linked to Khashoggi assassination monitoring.
The Russian IRA Operation: A Case Study
The Internet Research Agency, funded by oligarch Yevgeny Prigozhin (who later founded the Wagner Group), ran the most documented foreign influence operation in US history. Here's what the Mueller investigation and Senate Intelligence Committee found:
3,500+
Facebook ads purchased
Spending ~$100,000 total. Micro-targeted by race, location, and political leaning.
470
Facebook pages created
Mimicking American grassroots organizations on all sides of the political spectrum.
126M
Americans reached on Facebook
More than voted in the 2016 election (136.7M). Organic reach dwarfed paid ads.
10M+
Tweets from IRA accounts
3,814 Twitter accounts identified. Many had tens of thousands of American followers.
1,000+
YouTube videos
Totaling hundreds of thousands of hours of watch time.
187M
Instagram engagements
Instagram was actually the most effective platform — more engagement than Facebook.
The Most Insidious Tactic: Real Protests, Fake Organizers
The IRA didn't just post content — it organized real-world events. In one case, a Russian-created Facebook page called "Heart of Texas" (253,000 followers) organized an anti-Islamic protest outside a Houston mosque on the same day another Russian page, "United Muslims of America," organized a counter-protest at the same location. Real Americans showed up to both. Russian trolls in St. Petersburg watched on social media as Americans they'd manipulated screamed at each other in the streets of Houston. Total cost to Russia: a few hundred dollars in Facebook ads.
Cambridge Analytica: Weaponizing Your Data
While Russian operations were crude but effective, Cambridge Analytica represented a more sophisticated form of information warfare — one funded and developed by Western political operatives.
- ▸Data harvested: 87 million Facebook profiles collected via a personality quiz app. Users who took the quiz unknowingly gave access to all their friends' data too.
- ▸Psychographic profiling: Users categorized by OCEAN personality traits (Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, Neuroticism). Ads were tailored to psychological vulnerabilities.
- ▸Military origins: Parent company SCL Group had contracts with the UK Ministry of Defence and NATO for "behavioral change" programs — psychological operations rebranded for the private sector.
- ▸Global interference: Operated in elections across 68 countries including Nigeria, Kenya, Trinidad & Tobago, India, and the Philippines. Not just a US story.
- ▸Steve Bannon connection: Bannon was vice president and board member of Cambridge Analytica. He saw its potential for political warfare and brought it to the Trump campaign.
The 4th Psychological Operations Group: America's Mind Warriors
The US military maintains dedicated psychological operations units. The largest is the 4th Psychological Operations Group (Airborne), based at Fort Liberty (formerly Fort Bragg), North Carolina. In 2022, they released a recruitment video on social media that went viral — a slick, cinematic production with the tagline "Ghosts in the Machine" that openly advertised their mission: "Have you ever wondered who's pulling the strings?"
PSYOP Capabilities
- ▸Tactical PSYOP: Leaflets, loudspeakers, radio broadcasts in combat zones. In Iraq, dropped 31 million leaflets before the 2003 invasion.
- ▸Military Information Support Operations (MISO): Renamed from PSYOP in 2010 (rebranded back in 2017). Social media manipulation, website creation, content production.
- ▸Trans-Regional Web Initiative: Network of Pentagon-funded "news" websites posing as independent media in Middle Eastern and Central Asian countries. Exposed by Reuters in 2022.
- ▸CENTCOM fake accounts: In 2022, Meta and Twitter took down accounts linked to US Central Command that used fake personas to push pro-US narratives. The Pentagon was caught doing exactly what it accused Russia of doing.
The Military-Entertainment Complex
The Pentagon maintains entertainment liaison offices for every branch of the military. Hollywood studios that want access to aircraft carriers, fighter jets, or military bases must submit scripts for Pentagon review. Changes are demanded. Scripts that portray the military negatively don't get support — and without military equipment, many action films simply can't be made. The result is decades of films that function as recruitment propaganda.
Top Gun: Maverick (2022)
Pentagon support: Full Pentagon cooperation
Navy recruitment inquiries surged 500% after the first Top Gun (1986). Sequel got $150M+ in free military equipment access. Navy set up recruitment booths in theaters.
Marvel Cinematic Universe
Pentagon support: Scripts reviewed by DoD
The Avengers, Captain Marvel, and others received military support in exchange for favorable portrayal. When scripts weren't sufficiently pro-military (Hulk, Iron Man), support was withdrawn.
Call of Duty franchise
Pentagon support: Military advisors, marketing partnerships
Billions in revenue. Normalizes military operations for millions of young gamers. Army esports team recruited directly through gaming platforms until Congress intervened in 2020.
Zero Dark Thirty (2012)
Pentagon support: CIA cooperation — leaked classified info
CIA gave filmmakers access to classified briefings about the bin Laden raid. Senate investigation found the CIA shaped the narrative to credit enhanced interrogation (torture) for finding bin Laden. This was disputed by Senate Intelligence Committee.
Transformers franchise
Pentagon support: Full military cooperation
Michael Bay given access to aircraft carriers, fighter jets, tanks. Films are essentially recruitment ads with special effects. Combined gross: $4.8 billion worldwide.
By the numbers: Research by Tom Secker and Matthew Alford found that the Pentagon and CIA have influenced over 2,500 films and TV shows since 2000. This includes not just action movies but reality TV, documentaries, talk shows, and even game shows.
Media Consolidation & Defense Industry Ownership
In 1983, 50 companies owned 90% of American media. Today, just 6 companies control over 90%: Comcast (NBC/MSNBC), Disney (ABC), Paramount (CBS), Fox, Warner Bros. Discovery (CNN), and the New York Times Company. The concentration gets worse when you look at who sits on their boards.
The Defense-Media Revolving Door
- ▸CNN, MSNBC, and Fox News hired dozens of retired generals and admirals as "military analysts" during the Iraq War. A 2008 NYT investigation revealed many still had financial ties to defense contractors — and the Pentagon was coaching them on talking points.
- ▸General Electric owned NBC until 2013. GE was simultaneously one of the largest defense contractors — making engines for F/A-18 fighters, Apache helicopters, and Abrams tanks. NBC covered wars that made GE money.
- ▸Board members of major media companies frequently overlap with defense industry boards. The Intercept found that virtually every major media outlet had board connections to companies that profit from war.
Military Influencers: TikTok, Twitch, and the New Recruitment
As traditional recruitment declined, the Pentagon turned to social media influencers and gaming platforms to reach Gen Z. The results have been both effective and controversial.
- ▸Army esports team: The US Army created an esports team that streamed on Twitch, attracting young viewers with gaming content. When viewers asked about war crimes in the chat, they were banned. In 2020, the ACLU sued, and Congress barred the military from using Twitch for recruiting minors.
- ▸Military TikTok: Active-duty service members create viral content showing military life — workouts, deployments, weapons. Some are organic; others are coordinated through official channels. The line between personal content and recruitment propaganda is intentionally blurred.
- ▸$100M+ on gaming: The military spent over $100 million on esports partnerships, gaming sponsorships, and virtual recruitment events. They targeted 17-24 year olds — the same demographic most susceptible to propaganda.
- ▸Paid patriotism in sports: Between 2012-2015, the Pentagon paid $53 million to professional sports teams for "patriotic displays" — flyovers, color guards, on-field tributes. What looked like spontaneous patriotism was taxpayer-funded advertising.
Deepfakes & AI: The End of "Seeing Is Believing"
Artificial intelligence has fundamentally changed information warfare. Deepfake technology can now create convincing video of anyone saying anything. The implications for military propaganda and disinformation are staggering.
Military Applications
- • DARPA's MediFor program: $68M to detect deepfakes — but detection always lags creation
- • Special Operations Command (SOCOM) requested deepfake capabilities for "influence operations"
- • AI-generated voices can now clone anyone from 3 seconds of audio
- • Pentagon contracts with AI firms for "synthetic media" generation
Already Happening
- • March 2022: Deepfake of Zelensky telling Ukrainian troops to surrender circulated on social media
- • May 2023: AI-generated image of Pentagon explosion caused brief stock market dip
- • AI bots can now generate thousands of unique propaganda posts per hour
- • "Dead internet theory": growing percentage of online content is AI-generated
The Smith-Mundt Repeal: Legalizing Propaganda Against Americans
For 64 years, the Smith-Mundt Act of 1948 prohibited the US government from directing propaganda at American citizens. The law recognized a fundamental principle: a government that propagandizes its own people cannot be held accountable by them.
In 2012, the Smith-Mundt Modernization Act was quietly inserted into the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA). It passed with minimal debate and almost no media coverage. The law allowed the State Department and Broadcasting Board of Governors to disseminate materials "within the United States" that had previously been restricted to foreign audiences.
What Changed
Before 2012:
- • Voice of America, Radio Free Europe/Asia content banned domestically
- • Government-produced media for foreign audiences couldn't reach Americans
- • Clear legal firewall between foreign propaganda and domestic audience
After 2012:
- • All government-produced content can now be disseminated domestically
- • No requirement to label content as government-produced
- • Combined with social media, government can push narratives anonymously
The Libertarian Case: Free Press as the Check on Power
The Founders didn't put freedom of the press in the First Amendment by accident. They understood that a government powerful enough to wage war is powerful enough to lie about it — and that an informed citizenry is the only check on that power.
Government Propaganda Violates the Social Contract
In a democratic republic, the government derives its legitimacy from the informed consent of the governed. When the government spends $4.7 billion per year shaping what citizens think about war, that consent is manufactured, not earned. Every dollar spent on Pentagon PR is a dollar spent undermining the democratic process that supposedly legitimizes the government's authority.
The Smith-Mundt Repeal Was an Assault on Liberty
The 1948 law recognized that a government directing propaganda at its own citizens is incompatible with freedom. Its repeal wasn't "modernization" — it was the removal of a safeguard that existed for good reason. When your government can legally lie to you, every justification for war becomes suspect.
The Free Market of Ideas Requires a Level Playing Field
Libertarians believe in the free market of ideas. But when one participant — the government — has a $4.7 billion budget, 27,000 PR employees, and the legal right to propagandize its citizens, the marketplace isn't free. It's rigged. Every embedded journalist, every Pentagon-reviewed script, every paid patriotism event distorts the information citizens need to make decisions about war and peace.
Both Parties Are Complicit
The Smith-Mundt repeal passed with bipartisan support. Democrats and Republicans both benefit from a citizenry that accepts war without question. The military-media complex serves the interests of the state, not the people. As Randolph Bourne wrote in 1918: "War is the health of the state." Information warfare ensures the state stays healthy.
Defending Yourself Against Information Warfare
In an age of weaponized information, media literacy is a survival skill. Here's what individuals can do:
- 1.Check who's paying: When you see a "military analyst" on TV, check if they have defense industry ties. They almost always do.
- 2.Read international sources: BBC, Al Jazeera, Reuters, and AP provide perspectives absent from American media. Not because they're unbiased — because their biases are different from ours.
- 3.Be suspicious of viral content: If it makes you angry, that's the point. Emotional manipulation is the primary tool of information warfare.
- 4.Support independent journalism: The Intercept, ProPublica, the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, and local newspapers still do the work. They need funding.
- 5.Demand transparency: Push for reinstatement of the Smith-Mundt domestic propaganda ban. Demand that all government-produced content be clearly labeled.
The Bottom Line
Information warfare is the cheapest and most effective form of modern conflict. Russia spent $1.25 million per month and arguably influenced an American election. The Pentagon spends $4.7 billion per year ensuring Americans support the wars it wants to fight.
Since 2012, it has been legal for the US government to direct propaganda at its own citizens. The military reviews Hollywood scripts. Pentagon-funded "news" websites pose as independent media. Retired generals with defense industry paychecks appear on cable news as "objective analysts." Military influencers target teenagers on TikTok.
The Founders understood that an informed citizenry is the only real check on government power. That's why they put press freedom in the First Amendment. Information warfare — whether waged by Russia, China, or our own government — is an assault on that principle. And you are the target.
Sources & Further Reading
- • Associated Press, "Pentagon Spending Billions on PR" (2009)
- • Senate Intelligence Committee, Report on Russian Active Measures (2019)
- • Mueller Report, Vol. I: Russian Interference in the 2016 Presidential Election
- • Bureau of Investigative Journalism — ongoing drone strike tracking
- • Tom Secker & Matthew Alford, "National Security Cinema" (2017)
- • Carl Bernstein, "The CIA and the Media," Rolling Stone (1977)
- • New York Times, "Behind Analysts, the Pentagon's Hidden Hand" (2008)
- • The Intercept, "Pentagon Ran Secret Anti-Vax Campaign" (2024)
- • Reuters, "Pentagon Ran Covert Social Media Influence Campaign" (2022)
- • Randolph Bourne, "War Is the Health of the State" (1918)
- • Smith-Mundt Modernization Act of 2012, Section 1078, NDAA FY2013